Early Red Card Controversy: Did Yoro Deserve to Go?
22 November 2026
In a dramatic twist during Mauricio Pochettino's first match at the helm of Manchester United, Leny Yoro saw red just eight minutes in. This early dismissal marked the quickest red card in Premier League history for United, giving Liverpool the upper hand at Anfield.
The question on everyone’s lips: was it the right call? Many are pondering whether the video assistant referee (VAR) should have intervened to downgrade the decision to a yellow card instead.
Let’s unpack the incident that led to the red card. A long ball from Ronald Araujo found Alexander Isak, who took a touch before Yoro collided with him, sending him down. Referee Sam Barrott wasted no time in issuing the foul and showing Yoro the red card.
But was Isak guaranteed to gain control of the ball? If there was uncertainty, a yellow might have sufficed. Referees consider four key factors when determining if a foul denies a clear goalscoring opportunity: the distance to the goal, direction of play, likelihood of ball control, and the positions of defenders and attackers.
In this case, Isak was sprinting straight towards goal with no defender in sight, ticking off three of those boxes. The critical point, however, revolves around whether Isak was in a position to keep control of the ball. He had taken a heavy touch, pushing the ball away from him just before Yoro made contact.
This raises the question: would Isak have gotten to the ball ahead of goalkeeper Senne Lammens? If there’s any doubt, that’s grounds for not issuing a red card. Given the borderline nature of the situation, VAR wouldn’t likely intervene for what they deem a clear and obvious error.
On the punditry front, opinions are split. Danny Murphy, a former Liverpool and England midfielder, was unequivocal, stating there was “no doubt” about the red card. Meanwhile, Gary Neville, a former United defender, supported the decision as well, labeling Yoro’s challenge as clumsy and naive.
Interestingly, similar situations have unfolded this season. Pascal Struijk of Brighton faced a red card at Sunderland after a VAR review, but later had it overturned on appeal due to doubts about whether the opposing player would have controlled the ball.
Could United also appeal Yoro’s red card? It might be worth a shot, as they have nothing to lose. Even though the Football Association ruled Struijk’s red card as incorrect, the Premier League panel had a split vote on the VAR's call.
Another incident involved Ipswich’s Issa Diop, who avoided a red card after the referee disagreed with the VAR's assessment, believing there was a covering defender. This highlights the subjectivity surrounding these decisions, often leading to a lack of consensus.
Yoro might feel a bit hard done by, as the controversy surrounding his early dismissal continues to swirl.