← All news

Thrilling Stalemate: Newcastle and Arsenal Share the Spoils

21 November 2026

Newcastle and Arsenal served up a thrilling 2-2 draw at St James' Park on Saturday, with both teams delivering an exciting second half. Eberechi Eze put the Gunners ahead in the first half, but Harvey Barnes was quick to bring the hosts back on level terms after the break. Things heated up as Malick Thiaw scored to give Newcastle the lead from a corner, but Noni Madueke responded with a stunning strike to equalize for Arsenal, ensuring the match ended in a dramatic stalemate. BBC Sport's Alex Howell has shared his player ratings for the match, and fans can weigh in with their opinions as well. Starting with Newcastle, goalkeeper Lukas Hornicek had a challenging night. His kicking was inconsistent, and he faced pressure from Kai Havertz, leading to criticism for his role in Arsenal's second goal. Rating: 5. Amar Dedic struggled against Eze and received a yellow card for pulling him back. His performance left much to be desired. Rating: 5. Malick Thiaw was one of the standout performers for Newcastle, scoring their first goal and displaying solid defensive skills throughout the match. Rating: 8. Dan Burn made key defensive plays in the first half and was integral to Newcastle's goal. Rating: 7. Lewis Hall had a shaky moment leading to Arsenal’s opening goal but redeemed himself with crucial defensive interventions and effective crosses. Rating: 7. Sean Steur showed promise with his composure on the ball but was subbed off at half-time, leaving fans wanting more. Rating: 6. Lewis Miley worked well alongside Steur in midfield, contributing effectively in the second half. Rating: 7. Jacob Murphy had a quiet game and was replaced at the break after an early attempt on goal. Rating: 5. Joe Willock's energy and physical presence were vital for Newcastle's improvement as the match progressed. Rating: 7. Harvey Barnes shone with a brilliant equalizer and was a constant threat to the Arsenal defense. Rating: 8. William Osula had a tough night leading the line but played a crucial role in Newcastle's opening goal. Rating: 7. Substitutes made an impact, too, with Tino Livramento coming on and quickly making his mark. Rating: 7. Anthony Elanga's speed added depth to Newcastle's attack, while Jacob Ramsey injected energy into the midfield. Both earned ratings of 6 and 7, respectively. On Arsenal's side, David Raya had a difficult outing, leaving the pitch after sustaining a shoulder injury. Rating: 5. Jurrien Timber utilized his aerial skills but was part of a defense that struggled in the second half. Rating: 6. Ezri Konsa was relatively comfortable until Newcastle found their rhythm, while Gabriel Magalhaes was caught off guard by Osula, leading to a defensive lapse. Both rated a 6. Riccardo Calafiori had a quieter game than usual, not contributing as much offensively. Rating: 6. Declan Rice started strong but couldn't prevent Newcastle's resurgence. Rating: 7. Bruno Guimaraes faced a tough reception from the crowd and missed a golden opportunity to score. Rating: 5. Martin Odegaard made an uncharacteristic error that allowed Newcastle back into the match but redeemed himself with an assist for Madueke. Rating: 6. Eberechi Eze was pivotal, scoring the opener and consistently providing an outlet for Arsenal. Rating: 7. Noni Madueke was a thorn in Newcastle's side, scoring a brilliant equalizer and maintaining a dangerous presence. Rating: 8. Kai Havertz displayed clever play and was instrumental in Eze's goal. Rating: 7. Substitutes Kepa Arrizabalaga, Myles Lewis-Skelly, and Christos Tzolis contributed positively after coming on, with ratings of 6 and 7. As the player ratings close, they reflect the average scores submitted by BBC Sport users, showcasing the highs and lows of this exciting encounter.